The Eight Days of Chanukah in Elk Grove

When it comes to celebrating the December holidays, traditions that are not Christian get short shrift in Elk Grove.

First, there is this question: is it Chanukah with a C, or Hanukah with an H (and is there an extra K in there somewhere)?

I’m sure a scholar of Aramaic could answer definitively, but either way, it is that weird Jewish holiday that comes in December that is not Christmas, but sometimes gets celebrated that way.   

Chanukah is what’s known as a minor Jewish holy day, not nearly as important as Rosh Hashanah or Passover. It celebrates, so the story goes, a miracle when the oil lamp above the sacred ark kept going for eight days instead of burning out in one day, leaving the Temple in darkness. The story is multi-layered, as most Old Testament tales are, with a lot of rabbis weighing in on the history of the Jews to say what is or what isn’t so. You can get some sense of that from Wikipedia’s entry here.   

In places with large Jewish populations, Chanukah often vies in importance with Christmas (much to the rabbis' distress). Growing up, my own family gave short shrift to Chanukah, which I write about here.

In Elk Grove, the Jewish population, while not insignificant -- yes, really! - -is dispersed, both in location and in affiliation. There is no community center or temple here that can be the focus for celebrations of Chanukah.

A couple of years ago, some of us got together with one of the Sacramento synagogues and threw a Chanukah party here in Elk Grove,  in Del Webb’s social hall. We decorated and served latkes and played games and sang in the hope that it would be the beginning of a Jewish community in Elk Grove. It wasn’t.

So now, those of us in Elk Grove who pay attention to Chanukah do so on our own.

I thought perhaps we weren’t entirely forgotten, however, as the powers that market holidays would never miss an opportunity to make what in the Holy Land is called a shekel. In years past, offered an excellent selection of Chanukah decor. This year, nada. Not even a box of candles for the menorah. , which also used to have a Chanukah display, was offering only small rubber ducks wearing yarmulkes, and some dreidels.  

I thought to do a tour of the likely places to buy Chanukah goods so I could advise you, but I lost heart after finding nothing at and only a small table with the sparest of wares -- over by the onions -- at the .

While I was at it, I kept an eye out for Kwanzaa memorabilia too. After all, the Elk Grove African-American population is, according to the latest census figures, disproportionately large. But no, Kwanzaa too has no presence here.

I’m not sure why it bothers me so much that Christmas is the only holiday being acknowledged in Elk Grove, but I suspect it has something to do with the concepts of inclusion and exclusion. Growing up Jewish, you learn how to be the odd person out gracefully, if not graciously. You are always The Other, and if you have never been in that position, you don’t know how incredibly isolating it can feel.  When I saw the significant Chanukah displays at Home Goods several years ago, I felt -- well, validated is the only word for it. And now I feel, yes, invalidated.

I know what the arguments are. What I see as yet another missed opportunity for retail merchants in Elk Grove, they probably see as business prudence. They have not stocked merchandise that might not get sold because there might not be customers for it. Those customers, however, are still buying the merchandise; it’s just that they’re traveling into Sacramento to do so. Once again, then, Sacramento will get the tax benefits, and Elk Grove will be left with much of the pollution from all that driving to and fro.

In the end, I had a latke party for some friends on the first night of Chanukah. I lit the candle from the box I bought at the Nugget, said the prayer and translated it for my guests:  Blessed art Thou, oh Lord our God, King of the universe who has sanctified us with His commandments and commands us to kindle the Chanukah lights.

Even in Elk Grove. 

Kanika M December 29, 2011 at 09:53 PM
It's really funny, Jane, that I never thought about the fact that Elk Grove did not do anything to cater to the significant African American population here, let alone the Jewish population. I am an African American artist who sepcially made a lot of Kwanzaa gifts which I sold at the Kuumba Collective Art Gallery, Blue Moon Gallery, and Crocker Art Museum, all in Sacramento. My Facebook page and website were full of dates regarding the Kwanzaa "haps" in the area, but all of the "haps" were in the Sacramento area. Truthfully, I could have taken personal responsibility and advertised in the Elk Grove online website or put some of my Kwanzaa balls into the Elk Grove Fine Arts Center, but I did not think about it. You are right that Elk Grove does miss a wonderful opportunity here to market to a wider array of people, including AAs, Jews, Hindus, Moslems/Muslims, Buddhists, etc. We are such a diverse community; that's one of the reasons I moved here. Here's more info about Kwanzaa celebrations taking place all this week in Sacramento, should anyone be interested: http://www.kcra.com/news/30076342/detail.html KanikaMarshall.com
Marty January 02, 2012 at 06:38 PM
KM....perhaps you would like to attend one of the Multicultural meetings here in EG. I am sure they would welcome any suggestions. http://www.elkgrovecity.org/multicultural/index.asp
Jane Gassner January 02, 2012 at 08:40 PM
@KanikaM, I know and love your work! I've been to your house during an Art Walk. So I'm thrilled to see you on Patch. As I wrote that column, I was aware that much of the responsibility for minorities being invisible in the Elk Grove cultural scene is ours. I think Marty has the right idea: we need to broaden the voices on the scene.
M.Legison January 03, 2012 at 06:11 PM
Why do liberals slobber over government-sponsored multi-cultural programs? Do you really view their capabilities of organizing their own as that minimal? They don't need your help. They need to be set free to do it on their own, and thankfully, many do.
Bwood January 04, 2012 at 04:09 PM
"Set free" from what? Are they confined in some way?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »